How to reduce the signal attenuation caused by long cable?

In fact, I have a rather special dongle, like this:
(Please ignore the red arrow and the red box below)

In fact, I’m not very clear about its performance indicators … :sweat_smile: But I will consider adding a pigtail, thanks~

Nice set-up! Like the enclosure. Looks like an SMA chassis connector where your antenna lead attaches. Same issue though, the small SMA female chassis connector could easily be broken off with the large feedline connected directly.

For a neat and robust connection, one could replace the existing pigtail between the Feeyo board and chassis with one that has a female N chassis connector instead of the female SMA connector currently in place. It would have to be longer, not sure it would fit where the chassis connector is now, but maybe would fit close to the area highlighted (red reflection from the LED), and would require drilling a hole to fit the N connector. This requires some work and disassembly and re-assembly of the whole enclosure… just to eliminate one connection.

2 Likes

Great idea! Only I was unable to modify the enclosure due not have the proper drilling equipment. In addition there are some contractual restrictions that I can not carry out such destructive operations. :frowning: So I think I can just add a pigtail adapter.

Feeyo is is a Chinese aviation data company. Like FA, they are recently expanding their ADS-B coverage network. I currently use the antenna and receiver they provide to provide data to multiple upstreams, including the FA. (FA rejected to give a receiver to me, :joy: sad)

2 Likes

@ve4gls
@baiqi
@windigofer

My Setup showing antennas, RG6 coax & pigtails

.
Closeup

3 Likes

I do appreciate that you did show the table (which is why I do tend to use RG-6 in situations where I can use a 75ohm plug that will work with a 50ohm jack).

My main concerns with the setup as illustrated would be that there’s some areas that do introduce additional loss that might cancel out the RG-6 advantages:

a) My biggest would be with the N-to-F adapter on the antenna. If that is not specifically a 50ohm N to 75ohm F, you have pretty much the same issue I mentioned earlier–a 75 ohm N plug has a thinner inner conductor:

image

The tolerances ARE different enough that inserting a 50ohm N plug to a 75ohm N jack is capable of damaging the jack–and a 75ohm N plug in a 50ohm N jack is not going to make good mechanical or electrical contact (and thus is not going to work as well as with a 50ohm N plug :D).

In my experience, N-to-F adapters tend to be 75ohm all around, and I do know the FlightAware antenna is actually using a 50ohm N connector.

b) The F-to-SMA adapter also introduces some losses (not just from the adapter itself but the shift in impedances)–that’s not nearly as severe as the issue with the potential N connector mismatch, though.

The Cantenna of course doesn’t have the potential mismatch issue (as it uses a native F connector) and if the FlightAware antenna used some other type of connector at the base (BNC, SMA, pretty much anything really but N or TNC) I’d not really sweat the impedance mismatch for listening as that’s just a decibel or two. The worry I’d have is that the better performance of the RG-6 would be nullified by the fact the inner conductor of that N adapter’s just barely making contact at all!

TNC, this isn’t an issue (because 50ohm and 75ohm TNC adapters just aren’t cross-compatible at all!) but you DO have to watch this with N, and because of the fact there IS enough of a difference between 75 and 50ohm N connectors that one risks breaking something or having a bad connection by forcing things…I do try to match impedance with N adapters in particular.

Now, were I doing a similar setup, I’d probably be running LMR-400 if I reasonably could as it’s less attenuation overall, but if I couldn’t…probably a saner approach (that wouldn’t risk a dodgy connection with the N connector) is to get a specifically 50ohm N male to BNC female adapter, and then use a 75ohm BNC connector on THAT end of the RG-6 cable (yes, you can get compression-fit BNC adapters that work like compression F connectors, my usual go-to when dealing with scanner antennas is RG-6 quad-shield with BNC on both ends or BNC on one end and F on the other). The tolerance issues (and risk of breaking things) are nowhere near as severe with BNC as with N connectors.

To the original poster: I don’t know how close you are to some of the markets in Shenzhen/Guandong or Shanghai, but you could probably pick up a right angle N female to SMA male adapter (there’s a little loss but not quite as much as with an RG-316 pigtail; as your receiver is in a dedicated box with a bulkhead connector to outside I’m a little less worried about strain relief). Also you could probably have an N to SMA connector cable made up, I know there are plenty of places on both Amazon and Ebay here in the States that sell them and on Ebay in particular a lot of the sellers are Chinese based. (Alibaba and Baidu almost certainly have sellers if you’re not near the major electronics market areas.)

The cables might not be sold as LMR-400 or RG-8, by the way. Really high grade is RG-213, a common brand here in the States is Belden 9913, and you’ll probably see stuff like CA-400 or KRG-400 or the like. Same really goes for RG-6.

4 Likes

@windigofer
@ve4gls
@baiqi

This is the N-male to F-female adaptor I purchase to connect FA Antenna to RG6 coax.
It is working perfectly well since 2016.

https://www.amazon.ca/gp/product/B002Z8ZKKA

3 Likes

Here’s my current installation:

First image, FlightAware ADS-B antenna is just to the right of the anemometer. Below it is a 50MHz loop, behind the anemometer is our 5.8GHz ISP parabolic. The ADS-B antenna is at about 48’ above ground level.

Second image: RPI3B and R820T2 dongle in cabinet behind router. I removed the cover from the dongle because it was losing sensitivity after 2-3 hours, was thinking it might be getting too hot. One of these days I’ll take it out and replace the cover. Note the right angle MCX connector/pigtail running to the left and down. This is the same pigtail at the top of the last image in the nest of network cables. Note that between the male N connector from the LMR-400 and the filter I have two adapters. I do have a cable coming in to replace the two adapters to eliminate one connection.
Not having the cover on the receiver dongle gives a good impression of how delicate the little circuit board is…
**
edit: I always assume the use of 50 ohm N connectors… One would not want to mix 75 ohm with 75 ohm as they are really not compatable, you risk breaking the center (female) or not having a connection at all!

3 Likes

You may want to consider putting the dongle and RPI in metal cases.
I did it to reduce the RF interference.
I like the fan. I use one on my RPI in the attic. It would get too hot in the summer and throttle back.

You have great range. My only suggestion would be a cavity filter(Much narrow filter and less loss than the FA filter) and/or amp/FA dongle with built-in amp.
I use a hab/nevis amp with a cavity filter. My range is limited as my antenna is only 30m AMSL and I get splattered by NYC tourist helos, 500W birds flying over at 1500-200ft(I am on the flight path to La Guardia and NYPD and S76s flying past at 150-200ft.

3 Likes

I put the Wilson connector on my Amazon wishlist. There is no Wilson model # but hopefully that is it. Soon will buy the FA antenna with it.

Recently bought a 400+ ft roll of RG-6 for $10 at a thrift shop, so i am using that into the foreseeable future. Short runs, less than 50 feet.

I also use RG-6 for amateur radio HF, a big no-no i’m sure. Indoor & attic mag-loops mostly < 5 watts WSPR beacons. The 75-ohm cable introduces impedance problems, but i tune the loops for minimum SWR, and if necessary trim the length of the RG-6 to get a match. Budget operations.

For immobilizing cables so they don’t damage fragile connectors: i use “cable tie bases” and cable ties, stuck to the shelving. If the bases come loose, i use superglue to re-affix them. Not ideal for keeping furniture pristine, but it works fine for me.

1 Like

Wilson Electronics adapter 971128
.

For tranmitting, impedance matching is very desireable. An impedance missmatch means that a 100W transmitter may be able to transmitt say only 70W. To transmit 100W with impedance mismatch, one may have to use a 150W transmitter at substantial higher cost.

In case of receiving, since the power involved is in micro Watts or milli Watts, adding a low cost rf amplifier such as satellite in line amplifier, or Pro Stick’s built-in rf amplifier, can cover for mismatch losses at negligible cost.

Calculation of signal loss in dB for a 75 ohm equipment connected to a 50 ohm equipment:

The FA antenna has an input impedance of 50 ohms, and RG6 coax has impedance of 75 ohms, a mismatch occurs.

However, the mismatch loss when using 75 Ohm cabling with 50 ohm antenna will be very minimal at around 0.177 dB. So dont worry and mix the 75 ohm with 50 ohm system.

How I arrived at figure of 0.177 dB?
When 50 ohm mixed with 75 ohm,
Reflection Coefficient Γ = (75-50)/(75+50) = 0.2
SWR = (1+Γ)/(1-Γ) = (1+0.2)/(1-0.2) = 1.2 / 0.8 = 1.5

Mismatch Loss in dB = -10 log (1 - Γ²) = -10 log (1 - 0.2²) = -10 log 0.96 = 0.177 dB

3 Likes

Being cheaper than Wilson Electronic one, I have also purchased N-male to F-female adapter from China through eBay, and these also work OK.
These are cheap, but Chinese sent these to Canada by a sail boat :), so it took about two month to reach me.

2 Likes

Just FYI, the RPI3B enclosure, fan, and heatsinks came in a package though amazon.

“Smraza Case for Raspberry Pi 3”

I have the fan running on 3v, very quiet and lots of air movment. The case is very tough, you could likely drive over it and not damage the Pi.

1 Like

I also have a fan, but relatively noisy, so I let it open automatically at 45 degrees and closed at 35 degrees, in order to maintain a relatively stable temperature. :grinning:

1 Like

RG6 cable routinely has to run at 3000 MHz, way above the ads-b frequency (and losses increase significantly as frequency increases). So don’t worry about problems with RG6 .

I have many antennas running with RG6. Typical cable run is probably 50 feet and work fine with standard SMA to F adapters.
If it gets out to a 100+ feet , I will add a 10 db of amplification and a power injector to the system.

1 Like

@elpipila:

:+1: :clap: :+1: Fully agree.

BNC compression connectors some tools will work with. Got into that working a CCTV system several years ago. I am retired now so don’t have specifics but seems like I ended up with an Ideal brand tool that was called out in specs for BNC.

Did these work ok for you? I bought some from China on ebay and the F threads were not to spec. …couldn’t screw on an F connector. …link no longer available because it was 2015 when I bought them and ebay doesn’t have order history back that far it would seem.

楼主是国内的飞友么?看到了飞友的标志,哈哈哈哈

是的~


Yes, I am.