The blue stick is known as successor of the orange stick. It contain filter and LNA.
Both can deliver the same results depending on the location and environment.
So the answer to that question should be something like “Maybe, but”
Depends what you are looking for in the end mate. There are no perfect answers because so much rides on your location, antenna placement, and outside “noise”.
If money is not an object and you want to squeeze as much out of your system as possible, then I’d suggest looking into an AirSpy R2 for your radio, some good RF cable, a good filtered LNA like an Uptronics or RTL-SDR Triple-filtered (not currently available) and maybe a DPD or FA antenna.
If you want admirable performance without breaking the bank, then go with the FA Blue with some decent cable running to an FA Antenna. Between the two, they are probably the best bang for the buck that you’ll get for most locations.
Antenna placement is going to be the key and that’s where you’ll need to experiment the most. The rest mention popcorn because there are so many right answers to your question, but you haven’t clearly stated what your goals are and under what constraints you may be working under.
The best dongle cannot work properly without the rest of the environment.
Good Antenna
Good Cable
Good Environment (which might make additional filters or LNA required)
Only this in combination will give you best results
I have optimized my setup with the blue stick as much as possible. Any further improvement requires now at least an Airspy which is as almost as expensive as my whole setup
I’m looking for more hits, or capturing more flights than I currently do.
I have built a spider antenna and I have a good cable that is only about one meter in length.
Location is the best chance for tracking the most planes, you cannot merely buy your way to more traffic which I understand but there is a way to maximize what’s there which is what I am after.
I had a decent jump in traffic once I installed the orange dongle but if I can get even more with a blue then I’ll buy a blue one.
I read a review of the blue on amazon stating it filters out certain planes which would be counter productive towards tracking the most flights. Hence the question I asked. Which is best.
First check what your max range is. Then check on a regular site, what’s the current traffic is and compare it with what you get at this time.
Afterwards run investigation what possibly block your device from better reception. A filter could help, an LNA could help, a better antenna could help but it’s not guaranteed.
Another thing you should consider is comparing your stats with other stations near to you.
You will reach a point where you will not get more flights. The only option then would be moving away from your location.
You’ll need to move away from the spider more than likely and get something up on the roof if at all possible. Your message and plane count will increase substantially.
You still haven’t given any detail at all about your setup other than you have a homemade spider connected to an FA orange with meter of “good cable”. We can only assume it’s indoors unless you did some extra work on your spider… Have checked your potential range using https://www.heywhatsthat.com/ ? Have you run scans with your current setup to see what your location’s off-band noise pattern looks like? Are you sitting on your roof or in a basement with that meter of cable when comparing? Have stopped reading this after the first question mark?
You would get better answers when providing information or the answers you get here will be totally useless and as generic as the question. Need to figure out what sort of time and effort you want to put into your quest.
The blue dongle does not filter certain planes. I suspect they were referring to certain flights being hidden on the FlightAware site itself. The hiding of those flights is not related to the dongle being used.
I still have the original setup of a DirectTV amp, a filter and a different dongle… I went with the Orange one as it was said to be better and it was but now I think I’m down like 30% from where I used to be.
Going to swap out the orange for the blue this week.
Now you know why I said the question was ‘huge’. Enough popcorn for me.
As already mentioned, you’ll learn a lot along the way. Excellent info has already been provided. My ‘input’ will not be the best, but I think is what it’s called for for the moment.
My number one suggestion at this point is:
Replace the Spider with an FA antenna;
This change alone should increase the number of planes seen.
My number two suggestion is:
Replace the orange stick with the FA Pro+.
This can increase performance a bit more, specially if a non brick-wall filter is enough to deal with mild interference, if an issue.
Make sure the coaxial cable used is good, make sure there is no water ingress in the cable.
Nine out of ten people will see most/all they can see with the above hardware. As your interest for the hobby increases, you may throw more money into it, but the ‘law of diminishing returns’ starts to kick in.
Thanks, I’ll swap my Orange out for the blue one I have in SoCal. I know location is everything as my SoCal location tracks like 3k planes a day whereas NorCal is like 1K and I have the sane style Spider at both locations.
Being in CA there is little water intrusion as the song says, it never rains in Southern California.