Most of Indiana has gone to Daylight Savings Time. Your tracking ETAs do not reflect this change.
Short answer- give it a few weeks (Oct 29) and it will be fixed! (at least for six months)
Longer answer, the airport database does not currently reflect the change that most (but not all) of Indiana moving to Eastern time and the observation of DST. This should be perminatly fixed when said update done (search threads for timezone change.
And of course, welcome to Flight Aware forums, no matter what timezone your are in!